The 1896 Educational Series Silver Certificates
For one brief moment the Treasury handed the design of the dollar to painters. Three muralists filled the face of the $1, $2 and $5 silver certificates with allegory from edge to edge, the public complained, and the experiment was over almost as soon as it began. Collectors have been chasing the results ever since.
Series of 1896$1, $2 and $5 onlyThree muralistsReplaced by Series 1899
Last updated: November 2026
The Educational Series is the set of three Series 1896 silver certificates, the $1, $2 and $5, whose faces were painted by the muralists Will H. Low, Edwin H. Blashfield and Walter Shirlaw. The name comes from the $1 design, History Instructing Youth. Bank tellers and moral critics turned against the notes, and the Treasury replaced them with the plainer Series 1899.
What is the 1896 Educational Series?
It is a three-note set of silver certificates, the $1, $2 and $5 of the Series of 1896, whose faces were composed as murals rather than as portraits framed by machine-engraved patterns. The name is a collectors' label, not an official one: as Atlas Obscura explains, numismatists took it from the title of the $1 painting, History Instructing Youth. That $1 also rings its edge with wreaths, twenty-three of them, each enclosing the name of a notable American.
The project began in 1893, when Claude M. Johnson, Chief of the Bureau of Engraving and Printing, hired three artists and paid each of them $800 for every design the Bureau accepted (PMG, The Making of History, Part 1). Treasury Secretary John G. Carlisle authorized the series, and Low argued its case in 1893 with a line that still sums it up: it would mean putting "a work of art in the hands of every man who buys a loaf of bread" (Smithsonian Magazine).
The decision that made the notes famous was technical. To keep the paintings intact, the Bureau left the faces free of lathe work, the fine geometric patterns that had protected American notes for decades. PMG describes the three denominations as the only notes in United States history without lathe work on the front, and Chief Engraver Thomas F. Morris objected on counterfeiting grounds (PMG). Coin World, citing the researcher Gene Hessler, puts it slightly differently: the only federal notes since 1861 to go without it (Coin World). Coin World reports that the lathe-free faces did make the notes easier targets for counterfeiters.
Who designed and engraved the Educational notes?
Three painters supplied the faces and a team of Bureau engravers cut them into steel. Will H. Low painted the $1, Edwin H. Blashfield the $2 and Walter Shirlaw the $5, while Thomas F. Morris designed the backs and reworked borders, and engravers led by Charles Schlecht, G.F.C. Smillie and Lorenzo Hatch translated the art into plates.
The table sets out the credits as PMG's two-part history records them, with the $2 face engravers taken from the Smithsonian Magazine caption. Each back carries two portraits, and each pair answers the theme on the front.
| Note | Title of the face design | Artist | Face engraver | Portraits on the back | Friedberg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $1 | History Instructing Youth | Will H. Low | Charles Schlecht | Martha Washington (engraved by Charles Burt, 1878) and George Washington (engraved by Alfred Sealey, 1867) | Fr. 224-225 |
| $2 | Science Presenting Steam and Electricity to Commerce and Manufacture | Edwin H. Blashfield | George Smillie and Charles Schlecht | Robert Fulton and Samuel F.B. Morse (both engraved by Lorenzo Hatch) | Fr. 247-248 |
| $5 | Electricity as the Dominant Force in the World | Walter Shirlaw | G.F.C. Smillie | Ulysses S. Grant and Philip Sheridan (both engraved by Lorenzo Hatch) | Fr. 268-270 |
Credits from PMG Part 1 and PMG Part 2; $2 face engravers from Smithsonian Magazine. The $5 title is the one PMG uses; Coin World calls the painting Electricity Presenting Light to the World, and Smithsonian Magazine names the central figure America.
The paintings did not vanish once the plates were made. According to Hessler, as cited by PMG, five of the original canvases hang at the Bureau of Engraving and Printing. And the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco lists the 1896 $5 in its American Currency Exhibit.
What does the $1 History Instructing Youth show?
A seated woman, History, keeps one arm around a boy, Youth, and points him toward the capital, where the Washington Monument and the Capitol stand in the distance. The Constitution appears at the right. The scene is a civics lesson, and it set the tone for the name collectors later gave the whole set.
The design moved quickly on paper and slowly to press. Low's design was approved on May 10, 1894, the finished artwork was accepted on July 10, 1894, Morris redrew the borders and lettering, and printing did not begin until April 18, 1896 (PMG). Coin World notes a possible ancestor in Low's own work: his 1889 painting Love Disarmed, now at the Brooklyn Museum, pairs a seated woman with a winged little boy, and Coin World sees connections between the two pictures.
The $1 produced an "error" scare that was not an error. The New York Times of August 2, 1896 questioned the spelling of "tranquility" with a single l in the Constitution on the note, and PMG reports that the supposed mistake briefly traded at a premium of 10 to 25 cents. The spelling matched the Constitution as written, so the excitement came to nothing.
The back is where Morris held to tradition. Martha Washington sits at left and George Washington at right, with a large numeral 1 between them. PMG recounts that the arrangement drew its own complaint: the public objected that "no one should come between George and Martha Washington." PMG names five more engravers who cut the rest of the plate: James Kennedy, E.M. Hall, L.F. Ellis, G.U. Rose, Jr. and D.S. Ronaldson.
What is on the $2 and $5 Educational notes?
The $2 celebrates invention: Science introduces two children, Steam and Electricity, to the grown figures of Commerce and Manufacture, while Robert Fulton and Samuel Morse look out from the back. The $5 is the boldest of the three, a winged Electricity holding up a glowing bulb, with Ulysses S. Grant and Philip Sheridan on the reverse.
The $2: a composition built for a bigger note
The $2 was not supposed to be Blashfield's. Low had drawn a $2 called War and Defence, and Johnson asked for a string of changes, including removing a flag and softening the chin of the male figure, before rejecting it outright on January 5, 1895 (PMG Part 2). Blashfield's replacement had been composed for a $50. He told Johnson he could live with a $10 or $20, but not a single digit, because the pyramid of figures lost its effect at that scale. Johnson kept it as a $2 anyway. On the back, Hatch engraved Fulton, the steamboat pioneer, and Morse, the telegraph inventor, so the reverse completes the story the face begins.
The $5: Electricity and the gods
Shirlaw, a muralist who had also worked as an engraver, crowded the $5 with figures. PMG describes Electricity at the center with her bulb, Jupiter arriving in a chariot with a thunderbolt, Fame blowing a trumpet over a map of the United States, a bald eagle on guard and Peace with her dove, with Washington visible behind. At Morris's urging, Johnson changed the scrollwork around the border, and where Shirlaw had left blank shields at the sides, Morris added plant life. On the back, Morris and Hatch shared the design, Smillie was the main engraver and Hatch cut the portraits of the two Civil War generals, Grant at left and Sheridan at right.
Why are they called the most beautiful American notes?
Because the people who write about paper money for a living keep saying so. Coin World's William T. Gibbs calls them "the most beautiful federal notes ever issued," and PMG places them among the most beautifully made notes in the country's history. All three designs also rank high in Q. David Bowers and David M. Sundman's book The 100 Greatest American Currency Notes.
The beauty has a cause. Low, Blashfield and Shirlaw were muralists by trade, and the Bureau let each face run nearly the full width of the note and follow the original painting as closely as possible (Coin World). The result looks like a fine-art print because, in effect, it is one. That makes the series a fine illustration of intaglio banknote engraving: the engravers had to render soft painted figures in lines alone, with no lathe pattern to hide behind. The women on the faces are allegories, while Martha Washington on the back of the $1 is a real person; both kinds of portrait appear in our guide to women on banknotes.
The most famous surviving pieces underline the reverence. PMG reported on a set of three original sheets, one each of the $1, $2 and $5, carrying serial numbers 1 to 4. The sheets come in a bound folio with a three-page typed letter by Claude Johnson, who had bought them for himself; they are pedigreed to the Harry W. Bass, Jr. collection and were graded About Uncirculated 55 by PMG (PMG).
Why was the Educational Series replaced so soon?
Because the notes failed at the job money has to do. The dark faces smudged, tellers could not read the denominations quickly, counterfeiters found the lathe-free designs easier to copy, and some of the public objected to the partly unclothed figures. A new Treasury Secretary, Lyman J. Gage, wanted plainer notes, and the Series 1899 followed.
The objections arrived from several directions at once, as Coin World reconstructs them. The Washington Times of May 1, 1897 complained that the denominations were too indistinct for rapid use at banks, and the New York Times of August 15, 1897 noted: "The first objection to them was that they were new." Smudging made worn notes look suspicious, and the open faces gave forgers an easier target.
The $5 drew a moral campaign. In a letter dated January 25, 1898, Ellen Collins asked the Treasury to avoid the "indelicate figures" on the $5, and Hessler illustrates an 1897 proof on which the Bureau had added clothing to Electricity and Peace (Coin World). Smithsonian Magazine adds that, according to Hessler, the anti-vice campaigner Anthony Comstock demanded the notes be recalled. The Bureau worked on lighter faces, but Coin World and Smithsonian Magazine both report that the revised designs never reached circulation.
The decisive change was political. Gage became Secretary in 1897, disliked the series and said future notes would not be designed by painters (PMG Part 2). Smithsonian Magazine quotes him calling silver certificates, then nearly a fifth of the money in circulation, "dangerous." The Treasury promised a return to the old style of note, and the Series 1899 delivered it: the $1 became the Series 1899 $1, and Coin World notes that the 1899 $1 and $5 designs then lasted until 1923. Coin World sums it up: the Educational notes were replaced within two years.
Were higher denominations designed but never issued?
Yes. The Bureau planned to carry the series above $5, and work on a $10 went far enough that the Bureau later printed souvenir cards of its face. The criticism of the three issued notes stopped the program, and no denomination above $5 was ever released to the public.
Coin World reports that, as the complaints mounted, the government stopped work on the $10 and everything above it, and that the Bureau, after it began selling souvenir cards in the late 1960s, issued cards showing the 1896 $1, $2 and $5 and the unreleased $10. Smithsonian Magazine identifies the $10 as Shirlaw's design Agriculture and Forestry and quotes Morris worrying about its nearly nude central figures; the $10 never saw print. PMG's history says only that plans existed for a $10, a $20 and higher values before Gage arrived. Blashfield's $2, as noted above, began life as a design for a $50.
What have Educational notes sold for?
In December 2015 Coin World reported that high-grade examples had brought thousands of dollars and that well-circulated ones could be found for roughly $100 to $220. In that report, at a Heritage auction in September 2015 a $1 graded PCGS Currency Superb Gem New 67 PPQ brought $7,167.50, a $2 graded PMG Gem Uncirculated 66 EPQ brought $9,987.50 and a $5 graded PMG 66 EPQ brought $21,150.
A second $5 in that September 2015 sale, graded PCGS Currency Gem New 66 without the EPQ designation of the PMG note, realized $17,625 (Coin World, December 2015). Read each figure as one note on one date, not as a price guide. In that sale the $5 brought the most of the three denominations. For where these results sit among the country's major paper money prices, see the most valuable US banknotes, and for the wider story of the class, the history of US paper money.
When buying, check two things on top of grade. Look for heavy smudging on the black faces, the very flaw that doomed the series. And confirm the Friedberg number on the holder, since each denomination is catalogued under two or three numbers. Companion notes from the same era are the Bison note and the Grand Watermelon.
Planet Banknote is a family-owned dealership in Sarasota, Florida, led by a team with 15+ years in numismatics. Every note is sourced direct from mints, central banks, and authorized distributors, inspected through our Planet Banknote Verified process, and ships with a free Certificate of Authenticity. US orders ship free via USPS Priority, and every order includes a free bonus gift.
Frequently asked questions
Why is it called the Educational Series?
The name comes from the title of the $1 design, History Instructing Youth, in which a seated woman representing History teaches a boy; Coin World describes her pointing toward Washington, D.C., and PMG places the Constitution at the right. Collectors extended the name to the matching $2 and $5 silver certificates of the Series of 1896, which share the same mural style.
Who designed the 1896 Educational notes?
Three muralists painted the faces: Will H. Low the $1, Edwin H. Blashfield the $2 and Walter Shirlaw the $5. Claude M. Johnson, Chief of the Bureau of Engraving and Printing, commissioned them in 1893 at $800 per approved design. Thomas F. Morris designed the backs, and Bureau engravers including Charles Schlecht, G.F.C. Smillie and Lorenzo Hatch cut the plates.
Who is on the back of the Educational notes?
Each back carries two portraits. The $1 shows Martha and George Washington with a large numeral 1 between them. The $2 shows the inventors Robert Fulton and Samuel F.B. Morse, matching the steam and electricity theme on the front. The $5 shows the Civil War generals Ulysses S. Grant and Philip Sheridan.
Why was the Educational Series discontinued?
The faces were printed in heavy black ink, so they smudged and were hard for tellers to read at speed, and the lack of lathe work made them easier to counterfeit. Critics also objected to the partly unclothed figures on the $5. Treasury Secretary Lyman J. Gage, in office from 1897, wanted plain designs, and the Series 1899 silver certificates replaced the set after about two years.
Was there a $10 Educational note?
A $10 was designed but never issued. Smithsonian Magazine identifies it as Walter Shirlaw's Agriculture and Forestry, and Coin World reports that the Bureau canceled work on the $10 and higher values once the issued notes drew criticism. The Bureau later printed souvenir cards showing the face of the unreleased $10.
What is an 1896 Educational note worth?
Coin World reported in December 2015 that well-circulated examples could be found for roughly $100 to $220. At a Heritage auction in September 2015, a $1 in PCGS 67 PPQ brought $7,167.50, a $2 in PMG 66 EPQ brought $9,987.50 and a $5 in PMG 66 EPQ brought $21,150.