Skip to content
Shop planetbanknote.comShop →
Authentication Guide

Counterfeit Detector Pens: How They Work and Their Limits

A counterfeit detector pen is a marker that leaves a pale stripe on a good bill and a dark one on a bad bill. The chemistry inside is the starch test from a school laboratory, and it answers exactly one question about the paper. Here is what that question is, why the answer can be wrong in both directions, and what the agencies that protect US currency tell cashiers to do instead.

Active chemical: iodine Tests for: starch in the paper US patent filed 1990 Official advice: feel, tilt, check

Last updated: November 2026

Quick answer

A counterfeit detector pen holds an iodine solution that turns blue-black when it touches starch, which ordinary printer paper contains and US currency paper does not. A pale mark only means no starch was found. It does not prove a note is genuine, and the Federal Reserve warns that the pens are not always accurate.

How does a counterfeit detector pen work?

The pen is a marker whose reservoir holds an iodine solution instead of ink. When the tip touches paper that contains starch, the iodine reacts and leaves a dark mark; when there is no starch, the mark stays light. A US patent for the method, US 5,063,163, was filed on 20 March 1990 by Ach Group Inc., with Dov Carmeli named as inventor, and published on 5 November 1991 (Google Patents).

The patent describes a test solution of iodine in a solvent such as alcohol, with an alkaline iodide such as potassium iodide, and gives a working mix of about 0.5 to 2.0 percent iodine with roughly equal parts water and alcohol. It notes that the solution can be dropped on with a dropper or loaded into the reservoir of a pen-like writing instrument for quick use.

The chemistry is the classic starch test taught in school laboratories. Iodine does not dissolve well in water, so it is paired with iodide to form the triiodide ion. In the presence of starch, triiodide slides inside the coiled chain of amylose, one of the two molecules that make up starch, and the pair gives an intense blue-black color (Chemistry LibreTexts). The American Association of Chemistry Teachers, in a lab built around a 2019 ChemMatters article on counterfeit money, names triiodide as the key ingredient in the pens (AACT).

What color should the pen mark be?

On genuine US paper currency the mark should stay pale: the light golden-brown or yellowish color of the solution itself. On paper that contains starch, the mark turns bluish-black or nearly black almost at once. The patent describes exactly this split, with the test area on a counterfeit going from light golden-brown to bluish-black within a few seconds, and no immediate change on a genuine note.

The pen reports on the paper, not the note. A dark mark says starch is present. A pale mark says starch is absent. Neither result says anything about the printing, the portrait, the serial numbers or the security features. The U.S. Currency Education Program also warns that pens can generate false results (U.S. Currency Education Program).

The pale mark does not last forever. Joe Boling, writing to the numismatic newsletter The E-Sylum in 2007, reported that pen marks on genuine notes had become invisible or barely visible after three days, but were still prominent under ultraviolet light (The E-Sylum). That matters to anyone who handles notes as collectibles, as the last section explains.

Why doesn't genuine US currency react?

Because there is no starch in it to react with. The Secret Service describes US currency paper as 75% cotton and 25% linen, with small red and blue security fibers scattered through it (U.S. Secret Service). Chemistry LibreTexts lists cellulose among the substances that do not give the blue-black color with iodine; it is the amylose in starch that does.

Ordinary office paper is a different product. Boling put the difference down to sizing: in his words, "Crane's product is sized with animal fat and glycerine", while "commercial bond paper is sized with starch". The AACT lab notes make the same point from the other side: the starch in ordinary printer paper produces the deep blue, and the cotton and linen blend of paper bills does not. If you want to know more about what goes into banknote paper, our guide to banknote paper, cotton and linen covers it in depth.

How can a counterfeit pen give the wrong answer?

It can fail in both directions. A fake can pass if it is printed on paper that has no starch, and a genuine note can fail if something on its surface reacts with the iodine. The U.S. Currency Education Program names the two main tricks counterfeiters use against the pen: coating counterfeit notes so the chemical reaction cannot happen, and printing on bleached genuine notes.

The bleached note is the most important weakness. A note washed of its ink is still real currency paper, so it passes the pen exactly as a real note would, whatever is printed on it afterwards. The defence is not chemical at all. It is what the official training asks you to confirm when you hold a note to the light: that the watermark matches the portrait or denomination, and that the security thread matches the denomination.

False alarms on genuine notes come from contamination. Boling pointed out that older notes have spent a long time in circulation and have had many chances to pick up something that reacts with the pen. In an earlier issue of The E-Sylum, John Dannreuther described a restaurant cashier whose pen flagged one of a customer's 1950 twenties as bad; Dannreuther looked at the next bill the cashier took, judged it genuine, and suggested the old paper might not work with the pens (The E-Sylum).

Does a counterfeit pen work on old bills?

Not reliably, and specialists disagree about why. The E-Sylum's editor reported in 2007 that the pens carried a warning saying they did not work on money older than 1959. Numismatist Tom DeLorey replied that the currency paper was changed around 1960, and Dave Lange linked the change to the Bureau of Engraving and Printing's move from wet to dry printing in the same period, suggesting that wet-printed notes may all fail the pen test.

Boling disagreed that the date mattered. He marked a group of older notes, including five well-circulated 1923 silver certificates, 1928A silver certificates and 1934A Federal Reserve notes, and most did not react, while one 1928 five dollar United States note reacted mildly. The practical lesson is the same either way: on a note from the 1950s or earlier, a dark mark proves nothing, and the mark itself is unwelcome on a note a collector might want. Old US notes are authenticated by their printing, paper and design, which our history of counterfeiting page puts in context.

Do detector pens work on polymer or foreign notes?

A detector pen is no help with polymer notes. The Bank of England answers the question directly in its public leaflet, How to check your banknotes: detector pens do not spot counterfeits printed on polymer (Bank of England). Polymer issuers teach visual and tactile checks instead. The Bank of Canada's routine for its notes is to feel the raised ink, look at the metallic portrait in the large window, tilt the note to see the color changes, and flip it to check the window portrait against the large portrait on the front (Bank of Canada).

On foreign paper notes, the pen still answers only its one question, whether there is starch in the paper. It cannot tell you whether a note is the right size, carries the right watermark or thread, or matches its catalog description, and those are the checks that matter for world banknotes. Our pages on polymer vs paper banknotes, banknote watermarks and the full set of banknote security features describe what to look for instead.

What does the US government say to check instead?

The U.S. Currency Education Program, the Secret Service and the Federal Reserve all point cash handlers to the security features printed and embedded in the note. The Federal Reserve's advice is that the best way to judge a note is to rely on features such as the watermark and security thread, and that detection pens may give false results (Federal Reserve).

The official routine has three steps. First, feel the paper: a genuine note should feel slightly rough because of the printing and the paper. Second, tilt the note: on denominations of $10 and higher, the numeral in the lower right corner shifts from copper to green, and the current $100 adds a color-shifting bell in the inkwell and a blue 3-D security ribbon. Third, check with light: the watermark and the security thread should be visible from both sides and match the note's portrait or value (U.S. Currency Education Program, Teller Toolkit).

Under an ultraviolet lamp, the security thread in each current-style note glows its own color: pink for the $100, yellow for the $50, green for the $20, orange for the $10 and blue for the $5. If a note fails these checks, the program's instructions are to write your initials and the date in the border, handle it as little as possible, put it in an envelope, and hand it only to a properly identified police officer or Secret Service agent. The Secret Service itself asks members of the public to take suspected counterfeits to their local police department (U.S. Secret Service).

Detector pen vs other checks

Each check answers a different question, and only the security features answer the question that matters: whether this paper was printed as this denomination. The table sets the pen beside the other checks used on US paper currency.

Check What it tests What it can miss
Detector penWhether the paper contains starchFakes on bleached genuine paper, coated fakes, counterfeits printed on polymer; it can also flag contaminated or older genuine notes
FeelThe slightly rough texture of currency paper and raised printingIt only tells you something feels off; the program's advice is to move on to the security features when it does
TiltColor-shifting ink, copper to green; on the $100, the bell in the inkwell and the 3-D ribbonThe $5 has no color-shifting ink, and the ink appears only on $10 and higher
LightWatermark and security thread, visible from both sides and matching the denominationGenuine $1 and $2 notes have no security thread
UV lampThe thread's glow color for each denomination; fluorescent featuresSome counterfeiters try to imitate UV features, and LED key-fob lights often shine above the 365 nanometre wavelength the Bank of England recommends
MagnificationMicroprinting, such as the tiny words around the portrait and in the bordersIt needs a reference: the Secret Service guide lists different microprinted words for each denomination

Sources: Detector pen row from the U.S. Currency Education Program and the Bank of England; feel, tilt and light rows from the program's Teller Toolkit and training presentation; thread and microprinting details from the Secret Service's Know Your Money guide; UV lamp advice from the Bank of England.

Should a collector use a detector pen?

No. A collectible note is worth examining closely, not marking. The pen leaves iodine on the paper, and Boling found the marks still prominent under ultraviolet light days after they had faded to the eye. On notes from before the 1960s, where the pen may give a dark result on a genuine note, it does harm without giving useful information.

The better tools are magnification, a 365 nanometre UV lamp and a genuine note of the same type for comparison, together with the checks described above. Third-party grading is the other route for notes that justify it; our banknote grading guide explains how the grading services work, and the counterfeit-spotting guide walks through a full inspection.

Planet Banknote is a family-owned dealership in Sarasota, Florida, led by a team with 15+ years in numismatics. Every note is sourced direct from mints, central banks, and authorized distributors, inspected through our Planet Banknote Verified process, and ships with a free Certificate of Authenticity. US orders ship free via USPS Priority, and every order includes a free bonus gift.

Read Planet Banknote customer reviews

Frequently asked questions

How does a counterfeit detector pen work?

The pen contains an iodine solution instead of ink. Iodine reacts with starch to form a blue-black complex, and ordinary printer paper contains starch while US currency paper, made of cotton and linen, does not. So the mark turns dark on starchy paper and stays a pale golden or yellowish color on genuine currency paper. It tests the paper only.

What color does a counterfeit pen turn on a fake bill?

On paper that contains starch, the mark turns bluish-black or nearly black within seconds. On genuine US currency paper it stays the light golden-brown or yellowish color of the solution. The 1991 patent for the method describes this exact contrast. A pale mark only means no starch was detected, not that the note is genuine.

Do counterfeit detector pens actually work?

They catch counterfeits printed on ordinary starch-containing paper, but they miss fakes printed on bleached genuine notes or on coated paper, and they can flag genuine notes that are contaminated. The Federal Reserve says the pens are not always accurate and may give false results, and recommends relying on security features such as the watermark and thread.

Does a counterfeit pen work on old bills?

Not reliably. Pens have been sold with warnings against using them on money older than 1959, and collectors have reported dark marks on genuine notes from the 1950s. Another collector marked genuine notes printed in 1923, 1928 and 1934 and most showed no reaction. Either way, a pen result on an old note proves little and leaves a mark collectors would rather avoid.

Can you use a counterfeit pen on polymer banknotes?

No. The Bank of England states that detector pens do not spot counterfeits printed on polymer. Polymer notes are checked by their features instead: the Bank of Canada's routine, for example, is to feel the raised ink, look at the window, tilt the note to see the color changes, and flip it to check the window portrait.

What should a cashier do instead of using a pen?

Follow the U.S. Currency Education Program's routine: feel the paper for its slightly rough texture, tilt the note to see color-shifting ink on $10 and higher, and hold it to light to check that the watermark and thread match the denomination. If a note fails, write your initials and the date in the border and give it to the police or the Secret Service.